©2017 BY EMPIRE STATE BOOKSHELF. PROUDLY CREATED WITH WIX.COM

We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites

Archive

Please reload

Tags

My Rating System (And How It's Changed)

April 11, 2018

 

I've only been posting reviews of books for let's say 10 months or so but my rating system has changed a lot in those months. I will fully admit that when I look back on my old rating system I cringe a little because it was unnecessarily harsh, and I know for certain that I would rate those books higher now compared to what I rated them months ago. Part of me wishes I could go back and fix all of the reviews and ratings but I don't have the time for that so... hopefully I can catch and change some of those issues with rereads (yes, this is just an excuse for me to do rereads. Sorry?).

 

~The Old System~

 

1 Star: Didn't finish the book, absolutely hated it. I was dragging myself through every single page and I just couldn't stand it anymore (this is back when I didn't mark books as DNF)

 

2 Stars: I finished the book and I liked elements of it, but either really hated other elements or just couldn't stand the subject matter of the book. I will fully admit that some books probably got lumped in here just because they were genres that I didn't like, and so I now try and separate my feelings towards the genre from my feelings towards the book.

 

3 Stars: The book was pretty good. I wasn't head over heals in love with it, but I enjoyed it and would definitely read the following books if it was part of a series. This actually used to be my average rating for books, I rarely gave out anything higher than a  3, and was proud of it. I'm honestly not sure why, and I unfairly docked a lot of books for this.

 

4 Stars: This book was over-the-top amazing, I loved it with all of my heart and soul. I would totally buy it, I would read anything the author put out, etc.

 

5 Stars: This book destroyed my world. I almost never gave 5 star ratings. Ever.

 

~The New System~

 

1 Star: I actually don't give out 1 star ratings that often. The only book I gave a 1 star review to was back in November of 2017 and I haven't given one out since then. Most of the books that would be 1 stars I just mark as DNF and move on.

 

2 Stars:  This book was decent, it had elements in the story or plot that I really liked or had a good premise, but just didn't execute it in a great way. Maybe the characters were super unlikeable, or it was just not exciting enough for me to get through easily. I would maybe recommend this book to people, but most likely not.

 

3 Stars: This book was pretty good, and I would consider reading any sequels that came out in the future. I was more into the story and execution compared to a 2 star book, but there were still some elements, like a love triangle or circular plot, that held it back from that 4 star rating. I definitely enjoyed it though, and would probably recommend it to other people.

 

4 Stars: This book was awesome. I went through it quite quickly, and would 100% read the sequels when they come out. I would probably even buy this book too, and would definitely recommend it to others. There was maybe just one tiny thing that I had a quibble with that made me not rate it 5 stars, or maybe I just didn't have that "feeling."

 

5 Stars: I loved this book with all of my heart. I flew through the book, and was left wanting more. I would 100% buy the book, read the sequels, and recommend it to other people. I will reread this book over and over again, and never get bored of it.

 

I actually changed my rating system when I started posting reviews to NetGalley, since I realized that my rating system was much harsher than theirs was, and it was also much harsher than the Goodreads rating system. For the sake of compatibility I changed mine, and it's made life much easier for me now. It takes me a lot longer to decide on a rating for books now (I have to do a little soul-searching, and sometimes I decide after I write a review what the rating will be), but in the end I feel like I'm making more accurate recommendations and reviews.

 

So if you were ever wondering about the sudden increase in 4 & 5 star reviews... this is the reason why!

Please reload

Recent Posts

Please reload